Zinda hai Bhutto: For death can’t do us part – by Abdul Samad

by admin

There are some leaders who remain immortal, for whom death does not pose the same barriers that it does for others. Departure from this mortal world only serves to augment their fame as they reside then in people’s hearts. Pakistan’s first democratically elected president is a potent example of these very few. It is striking that even after three decades of the judicial murder that robbed the masses of their greatest benefactor; the common man refuses to accept the reality.

By engaging in slogans, Zinda hai Bhutoo Zinda hai, the line of mortality is breached and even death is transcended. For Bhutto did not represent only a mass of flesh but rather was the embodiment of compassion and affection for the marginalized and in his own right, constitutes an ideology. Such an ideology cannot be erased and as history testifies, powerful ideas remain entrenched in the psyche and mindset of people even after the passage of centuries. One may ask the question: What did this single man do that people cannot forget him?  The answer to this question cannot be fully captured in any language, for when human emotions come into the picture, words start to fail us.

The brutal way in which Bhutto was murdered only adds to his legacy. That he embraced death with open arms and refused to bow to the forces of injustice showcases a man of great mental and moral strength. It was this very compassion and ingrained sense of morality that allowed him to feel the sufferings of the indigent and the impoverished. It bears telling that Bhutto inherited a nation that was in utter denial and a profound sense of disbelief after the fall of Dhaka. That he was able to steady the ship after the violent storm may be one of his greatest achievements. I, for one, find Bhutto’s speech in the Security Council, one that was given at a time of great tribulation, to be utterly captivating despite his rather brazen tone. Here was a man who stood against all great powers when faced with the possibility of having to compromise Pakistan’s national interest.

This is not to say that Bhutto was without fault or that his tenure was one that was immaculate. His socialist policies backfired in the economic realm as growth slowed down and productivity plunged. His independent foreign policy, one that aimed to reunite the Muslim world, did not go down well with the United States.

That said, the purpose of this essay is not to scrutinize Bhutto’s performance for the simple fact that doing so after three decades hardly makes any sense. The aim of this article is to underscore how a leader, despite his flaws, can become such an intimate part of a nation’s soul that the two become one. Bhutto is the heartbeat of millions of destitute Pakistanis, for whom the word not only serves as a reminder of the man that was but also as an everlasting beacon of hope. Hope, the promise of a better future and expectation of prosperity can be a very powerful motivator. Bhutto resides in the nation’s soul for he allowed people to dream, to see beyond their present suffering in the quest of a greater Pakistan. And once, a leader becomes a part of people’s dreams and their aspirations, nothing can remove that vision from the public imagination.

Abdul Samad
Georgetown University
School of Foreign Service in Qatar

3 Comments to “Zinda hai Bhutto: For death can’t do us part – by Abdul Samad”

  1. Abdul Samad sb,..This was bhutto who has created space for MULLAHS in Pakistan…it aws Bhutto who has supported NAPAK ARMY of Pakistanwhen they were down after the loss of 1971 war….It was Bhutto who has tried to appease MULLAHS by banning alcohal,banning horse racing,friday holiday,anti ahmedia ammendment….Why bhutto had taken all fudals back to his party after they lost election to ordinary workers of PPP….I can mention many many contadiction in Bhutto sahib politics….have read the so called LAND REFORMS of Bhutto ..how the feudals were protected in that reforms..

  2. I do not, in any way, say that Mr Bhutto’s regime was without any fault.If you notice, I have even criticized him in my article. Your points are very valid. The whole point of this article is to show how close Bhutto was to the common man and how the masses still think about him even after three decades. I do not want to comment on his regime for I have not witnessed it firsthand. What I do not know, being the member of this generation, is that he left a mark on the aspirations of the the millions of impoverished people of Pakistan. It is, for this reason, that I salute the man and not for his other actions.

  3. Corrected Version

    I do not, in any way, say that Mr Bhutto’s regime was without any fault.If you notice, I have even criticized him in my article. Your points are very valid. The whole point of this article is to show how close Bhutto was to the common man and how the masses still think about him even after three decades. I do not want to comment on his regime for I have not witnessed it firsthand. What I do know, being the member of this generation, is that he left a mark on the aspirations of the millions of impoverished people of Pakistan. It is, for this reason, that I salute the man and not for his other actions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: